It never ceases to amaze me when an actor is the spitting image of the real person they are selected to play. I do not think a historical portrayal necessarily lives or dies by the performer’s resemblance to the subject, but I think it is something to appreciate, especially when you consider the amount of biopics starring actors who bear absolutely no resemblance to their role. Here are a few notable examples of actors who were clearly hired for their talents above anything else.
Michael Shannon As Elvis Presley (Elvis & Nixon)
The most requested photo in the National Archives depicts Elvis Presley shaking hands with Richard Nixon in the Oval Office, and the events surrounding this historic meeting at the White House are dramatized in 2016’s Elvis & Nixon. Kevin Spacey makes for a visually believable depiction of the 37th United States President, but the otherwise wonderfully talented Michael Shannon simply does not cut it as the one many call the King of Rock ‘n Roll, even with a decent jumpsuit and wig.
legendary Western movie star was cast as the Mongol chief in 1956’s The Conqueror, which has since been regarded as one of the worst films ever made.
music biopic Nowhere Boy focuses on the pre-Beatles life of John Lennon, as portrayed by Aaron Taylor-Johnson. If you ask me, the Golden Globe-winning actor might have been a better fit to play, perhaps, Paul McCartney or, better yet, George Harrison.
Tom Cruise’s portrayal in 2017’s American Made would have been criticized as one of the most egregious miscastings in Hollywood history. The otherwise talented movie star did absolutely nothing to alter his appearance and pass for the ill-fated, heavy-set CIA smuggler, save what I regard as an embarrassing Southern accent.
Julia Roberts gives, arguably, the finest performance of her career as a single mother and paralegal who uncovers a small town pollution scandal in Steven Soderbergh’s Erin Brockovich from 2000. However, if a resemblance to the person an actor is portraying were part of the Academy’s voting criteria, she might not have won the Oscar.
Ridley Scott’s 2007 biopic American Gangster dramatizes the career of mobster Frank Lucas, played by Denzel Washington, and also stars Chiwetel Ejiofor as Lucas’ brother, Huey. Curiously, Ejiofor actually looks a whole lot more like the real Frank than the two-time Oscar winner. However, Washington was a good friend and frequent collaborator of the director’s brother, Tony Scott, so he probably had the role in the bag for that, among other reasons.
Johnny Depp, who played the Peter Pan author in 2004’s Finding Neverland, does not boast a resemblance to either of them, if you ask me.
historical inaccuracies from The Greatest Showman, 2017’s musical retelling of the origins of the circus, and even ignore the fact that P.T. Barnum was not the kindhearted man Hugh Jackman portrayed him as. All that matters to this list is whether or not the Wolverine star looked the part, and the famously attractive Australian actor most definitely was not a match for Barnum in that regard.
Michael Fassbender’s Oscar-nominated performance in director Danny Boyle and writer Aaron Sorkin’s Steve Jobs from 2015 is widely regarded as superior to Ashton Kutcher’s portrayal in Jobs from two years earlier. However, at least the former That ’70s Show cast member can say he resembled the tech pioneer more closely.
surprise SNL cameo, during which he stood right next to host Jesse Eisenberg on the Studio 8H stage, proving that they are certainly not a visual match. The actor does not even bother to imitate the Facebook founder’s distinctly low voice when portraying him in 2010’s The Social Network, but his Oscar nomination proves that that is not what really matters in the end.
best collaborations with the director, Martin Scorsese.
beloved TV sitcom, I Love Lucy. However, playing her onscreen husband is Oscar winner Javier Bardem, who does not pass for Desi Arnaz in the slightest.
beloved sports movie.
Charlize Theron became Megyn Kelly for Bombshell. Clive Owen adopted this method to play Bill Clinton on Impeachment: American Crime Story, but the makeup only caused the English actor to resemble the 1990s-era President even less.
Best Picture Oscar winner, Amadeus, from 1984. However, the actor is widely admired for his performance as Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, which earned him a well-deserved Academy Award nomination.
Patch Adams hates Tom Shadyac’s biopic based on his life, which has nothing to do with the fact that Robin Williams looks nothing like the influential doctor. However, it’s still impossible to ignore, especially with how they do not even bother to give the Oscar winner Adams’ signature mustache.
the actor would later admit she regretted.